This one I kept pretty simple. Chose a box that was about the width of the construction paper so I didn't have to make extra cuts for the back ground. I have a plethora of amazon boxes to choose from, of course.
I glued on an orange construction paper background to a box, cut out the shapes to make the monster (and forgot to make him a shirt so colored it in with my trusty sharpie!).
I glued his hand on slightly skewed so that there is a pocket to slide in a treat - some pencils from Dollar Tree.
Fortunately my kids are young enough that they won't be too critical of my artwork.